【 RNI-HIN/2013/51580 】
【 RNI-MPHIN/2009/31101 】
Jansamparklife.com
Accused Need Not Be Under 'Formal Arrest' For Purpose Of Statement Given U/S 27 Evidence Act: Madhya Pradesh High Court
14 Nov 2022
Madhya Pradesh High Court- Principal Seat at Jabalpur
The Madhya Pradesh High Court recently observed that an accused need not be under formal arrest for the purpose of statement given under Section 27 of the Evidence Act.
While deciding a criminal appeal, the division bench of Justices Sujoy Paul and P.K. Gupta noted that the two ingredients to validate a statement under Section 27 are-
Person must be accused of any offencePerson must be in the custody of a police officer; they need not be under formal arrest.
Facts of the case were that the Appellant was convicted under Section 302 IPC for murdering his roommate. His conviction was based on circumstantial evidence as well as his statement under Section 27 of the Evidence Act, whereby he had informed the police about the location of the dead body and other incriminating materials. Challenging the guilty verdict, the Appellant preferred an appeal before the Court.
The Appellant submitted that his conviction was primarily based on the theory of "last seen together". It was further pointed out that the Prosecution had also heavily relied on his testimony under Section 27 of the Evidence Act. He argued that his statement under Section 27 was recorded prior to his arrest and therefore the same was inadmissible in the eye of law. It was also contended that the Prosecution had failed to establish motive before the trial court. It was further asserted that there were several contradictions and omissions in the testimonies of witnesses. Thus, it was prayed that his conviction be set aside.
Per contra, the State argued that the trial court had rightly convicted the Appellant by correctly weighing the circumstantial evidence stacked against him.
Examining the submissions of parties and the trial court record, the High Court did not find merit in the contentions put forth by the Appellant. The Court noted that mere absence of motive would not absolve the Appellant, especially when the chain of circumstances was established against him-
In our view, the existence of motive in cases of circumstantial evidence certainly assumes greater significance and importance. However, as a rule of thumb, it cannot be said that in no case, in absence of motive accused can be held guilty. If circumstantial evidence are clear and complete chain of circumstances are established which clearly proves that accused alone had committed the offence, the accused can be held guilty.
With regard to the evidentiary value of Appellant's statement under Section 27 of the Evidence Act, the Court held that it could not be rejected on the ground that he was not formally under arrest. Distinguishing between the terms "arrest" and "custody", the Court opined that the provision requires the person to be in the custody of the police officer. Therefore, the validity of his testimony under Section 27 was upheld-
A simple reading of this section shows that 'a person must be accused of any offence' and that he must be 'in the custody of a police officer' and it is not necessary that such an accused must be under formal arrest. We find support in our view from catena of judgments and a glance of said judgments shows that the question aforesaid is no more res integra.
With the aforesaid observations, the Court noted that the Prosecution had established their case beyond reasonable doubt. It further held that no ingredients were available on which its interference in the decision of the trial court was warranted and accordingly, the appeal was dismissed.
Case Title: ASHUTOSH KAITHWAS VERSUS THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH
Latest Updates
Bhopal Mayor Malti Rai gets notice in 15 years old corruption case, BJP's fresh patch of dirt in Bhopal Municipal
साल के पहले सवेरे को सलाम इन्साफ के पहले सूरज को सलाम!
After high -level drama, Congress face Gurjar finally elected as President; both husband-wife removed from Congress party
नाबालिग़ को बहला फुसलाकर किया अगवा! परिवार गम के साए में नम!
प्रदेश के 8 जिलों से PFI के 21 नुमाईंदों को गुपचुप ढंग से पुलिस ने उठाया!!
Fire breaks out in the wooden warehouse near Bharat Talkies Bhopal, goods worth 18 lakhs burnt to ashes
लंबे वक़्त से जंगल मे जिंदा बन्दूक के कारखाने में कैसे दाख़िल हुई मप की बड़वानी पुलिस???
Collector Lavania to hear the matter of Congress candidate Santosh’s OBC certificate dilemma
Bhopal-Nagpur National Highway-69 collapses, traffic diverted
IAS Varadamurthy's entry into politics, forms new political party to field candidates in next elections
JP Nadda for a 3 day visit in MP, to be present in Bhopal today; roadmap for the upcoming assembly to be drawn
तब्लीग़ी जमात को बदनाम करने वाले अवैध मेले का हुआ सूपड़ा साफ
सीता माता की मिसाल देने वाले कट्टरवादी विधायक मुफ्ती के खिलाफ क्यों नही अपराध दर्ज़?
शिवराज सिंह का कमलनाथ सरकार पर तंज
7 year old boy losses his life in Jabalpur while playing from a noose which got stuck in his neck
About Us | Contact Us | Privacy Policy | Rss Feed
Total Visitors :- 384651